PRODUCT DIRECTION REVIEW · Current Brickell evidence + working Acadia choice · No formula, claim, package, or product is released
Daily Face Wash · Working product decision

Use the cleanser Brickell already knows how to make.

Keep the current gel platform, give it an Acadia scent, and use the existing hyaluronic-acid version as the first product candidate. That is a controlled adaptation—not months of new cleanser development.

Confirmed in current Odoo evidence Recommended Acadia direction Exact release held
Recommended low-development route

Same gel base. Existing HA add-in. New scent.

Current Brickell records show both the regular Clarifying Gel Face Wash and another active face wash that already combines the same gel base, an existing hyaluronic-acid serum, and a separately added scent.

What stays known

The operating platform

  • Current Brickell gel cleanser base
  • Existing compounding and fill family
  • Current exact 3.4 oz / 100 mL operating format
  • Existing modular active-addition precedent
Three fast bench choices

One control, one recommendation, one challenger.

Joe controls the exact formula and process. These are the three questions worth answering—not an open-ended R&D program.

A · Fastest fallback

Scent change only

Current gel base plus the new Acadia fragrance. If the other additions cause trouble, this preserves the fastest launch route.

B · Recommended

Existing HA architecture

Use the same base + existing hyaluronic-acid serum structure Brickell already runs, then change only the scent.

C · Only if worth it

Niacinamide + B5

A recognizable alternative story, but it creates more formulation work. It should not delay Batch B unless marketing expects a material benefit.

Working five-product platform map

Four intended unchanged platforms. One controlled cleanser adaptation.

The goal is not to sprinkle ingredients into everything. Keep a selected formula unchanged only after its controlled identity, rights, specification, and INCI are reconciled; change a package, scent, or one controlled input only when the commercial value is real.

01
AM + PM

Daily Face Wash

Current gel cleanser platform and current HA-serum add-in precedent.

Acadia change

New quiet cedar / green citrus scent; existing HA architecture is the recommended bench candidate.

Short adaptation

Keep scent-only as fallback.

02
AM

Vitamin C Serum

Current unscented Repairing Vitamin C route.

Acadia change

Intend to change package and brand only in a working 15 mL pack. The current internal analog contains sodium ascorbyl phosphate and an HA-solution input; exact operating identity, rights, stability, INCI, and customer claims remain held.

Unchanged candidate

Controlled identity and claims held.

03
AM

Daily Moisturizer

Current unscented moisturizer-platform candidate; the operating bulk record is misnamed and has no active formula BoM in the current snapshot.

Acadia change

Intend to move the existing bulk into a working 30 mL pack without formula changes, but only after Joe retrieves and reconciles the controlled bulk specification, master formula, rights, and INCI.

Platform candidate

Dossier reconciliation and package trial required.

04
PM · Every other night

Retinol Serum

Current unscented Retinol Facial Serum route; introduce gradually before the working alternating-night schedule.

Acadia change

Intend to use the existing formula unchanged in a working 15 mL pack designed to meet the released light, oxygen, compatibility, and dispense requirements. Retinoid identity and strength are formula-defining—not sprinkle-in territory.

Unchanged candidate

Working every-other-night use; identity, strength, dose, warnings, and pack held.

05
PM

Night Face Cream

Current richer unscented cream-platform candidate.

Acadia change

Intend to use the richer unscented route unchanged in a working 30 mL pack after Joe reconciles the controlled identity, rights, specification, and INCI. Confirm whether the formula supports “fragrance-free” before using that term.

Platform candidate

Dossier reconciliation, tube dispense, and evacuation required.

Current evidence boundary: These are working source-platform selections from read-only Odoo BoMs and manufacturing history. They are not Acadia formula releases. Joe/Product must confirm the controlled RP/RT identities, exact specifications, rights, process, package fit, testing, labeling, claims, and final fills.
Working sell story

Product proof without ingredient theater.

Morning + night

Daily Face Wash

A clear gel-cleanser candidate with an existing hyaluronic-acid add-in precedent, assigned to the working first slot in both the morning and evening routes.

Working copy only: The exact Acadia formula, sensory result, directions, ingredient list, and claims still require Product/Quality release.
ACADIA · EDGE OF DAYMORNING + NIGHT
100 · 15 · 30 · 15 · 30 mL

The plan consolidates the working quantities for the period into one shipment. Final quantities and container forms remain held.

What Joe actually needs to answer

A short controlled adaptation—not a blank sheet.

01Confirm the controlled baseResolve the current RT/RP formula-code relationship and pull the released specification.
02Bench the three candidatesCompare pH, viscosity, clarity, odor, foam, rinse, afterfeel, and pumpability.
03Reject quicklyDrop any version that meaningfully moves the base or creates process/dispense trouble.
04Release the winner correctlyRun the Quality-approved stability, micro/preservation, package, line, safety, and claim review.
Rule for all five products

Use the closest current operating platform. Change only what earns its complexity.

Vitamin C and retinol are formula-defining, so the intent is to keep the selected operating routes unchanged while Joe reconciles them to controlled formula records. The moisturizer and night cream are also intended unchanged, but their controlled identity, rights, specification, and INCI must be reconciled before package qualification can release them.

Next product task

Build one five-row platform map: exact current analog, bulk/formula identity, existing package/process, current evidence, proposed Acadia change, and estimated release burden. Unknowns stay blank.

Working direction only

No formula or production action is released.

This review action cannot create a formula, BoM, SKU, manufacturing order, purchase, supplier message, claim, product, or external write.

Recommended bench candidate: current gel platform + existing hyaluronic-acid-serum architecture + new Acadia scent. Joe and Product/Quality control the exact identity, formula, test plan, claims, and release.